|
I
come from a family of teachers, so perhaps I’m
genetically programmed to stand in front of a classroom.
Maybe that’s the motivation behind the engine building
classes that we conduct regularly at Reher-Morrison
Racing Engines. What I’ve discovered, however, is that
a teacher learns as much from the students as the
students learn from the teacher.
When
a racer attending one of our seminars asks why we
prepare a part a certain way, I have to think about the
experiences that led us to adopt a particular technique
or choose a specific engine component. A case in point
is the lowly wrist pin – one of the most overlooked
yet most important components in any motor.
The
wrist pin is a crucial link in the chain that connects
the power to the pavement. It has to withstand the full
force of the cylinder pressure while accelerating
several thousand pounds of race car. Yet racers who will
gleefully study cylinder head airflow graphs and
camshaft profiles for hours seldom give any thought to
the wrist pins in their engines. Let’s face it: Wrist
pins simply aren’t sexy.
I’ve
built racing engines for more than 30 years, and have
always subscribed to the belief that lighter is better.
But recently I’ve had to reevaluate my thinking in
regard to wrist pins. I’ve come to the conclusion that
as power levels have escalated, many racers are using
wrist pins that are just too light. I’ve also realized
that some of the parts that extract more horsepower from
an engine also increase the stresses on the wrist pins.
Racing isn’t exempt from the rule of unintended
consequences: Every solution breeds new problems.
When
selecting parts for a racing engine, the general rule is
“light is good.” For example, a lightweight
crankshaft assembly require less power to accelerate
than a heavy crankshaft assembly, and therefore more of
the engine’s output can be used to accelerate the race
car. But if the parts are so light that they deflect and
deform under high loads, then the result is the exact
opposite – more friction is created and more power is
siphoned off in the form of heat that destroys the pins,
pistons, and connecting rods.
In
reality, more power equals more cylinder pressure, so we
have to select parts that are appropriate to the
engine’s power levels. Once you go beyond a set of
off-the-shelf pistons, the choices of wrist pin
material, diameter and wall thickness become critical.
When
a customer orders a set of wrist pins, the first
question I ask is, “How powerful is the engine
you’re building?” A set of tool steel wrist pins
with a .090-inch wall thickness might be fine for a
small-block Super Stock engine, but a 1,000-horsepower
big-block typically needs pins with .150-inch wall
thickness – and the pins must be correspondingly
thicker for a nitrous-injected engine. The wrist pins
used in blown alcohol and nitro-burning engines
illustrate just how strong the pins must be to survive
under extreme conditions.
A
catastrophic pin failure is an expensive way to learn
that the pins are too light. Fortunately there are some
early warning signs that indicate the pins are
overstressed. Black streaks in the pin bosses or the
small ends of the connecting rods are danger signs. In
more advanced cases there may be aluminum welded to the
pins from the piston pin bosses and rods (in the case of
aluminum rods). With steel rods, look for signs of
distress in the bronze bushings in the small ends of the
rods. These problems are usually the result of wrist pin
deflection, insufficient clearance or inadequate
lubrication.
Wrist
pin problems were rampant in Pro Stock several years
ago, and the cure was to apply some very expensive
coatings. Spending $800 for coated pins is not a
cost-effective solution for most sportsman racers,
however; the object is to make as many runs as possible
at a reasonable price. Assuming that the wrist pins have
adequate strength, it’s possible to head off many
problems simply by ensuring that the pins have adequate
clearance and lubrication.
The
crankcase in an engine with a conventional wet-sump oil
pan is awash in oil. If there is a condition that’s
heating up the wrist pins or stressing the piston and
rod bores, the sheer volume of oil in the crankcase will
carry off the excess heat. But a well-designed oil pan
with a kick-out, crankshaft scraper and a vacuum pump
(or a good dry-sump system) will dramatically reduce the
amount of oil in the crankcase. While an efficient oil
system reduces windage and increases horsepower, it can
also put the wrist pins in jeopardy – another instance
of unintended consequences. In fact, the wrist pins in
the even-numbered cylinders are often the first to show
signs of distress caused by insufficient lubrication
because they are on the side of the engine that has much
of its lubrication stripped away by the crankshaft
scraper and oil pan kickout.
In
this situation, my recommendation is to increase the
wrist pin clearance. Most engine manuals recommend wrist
pin clearances between .0008 and .0010-inch for
conventional engines; my advice is to run .0020 to
.0022-inch wrist pin clearance in a serious drag racing
engine. My perspective on engine clearances is
straightforward: When in doubt, a little loose will
seldom result in catastrophic failure, but a little too
tight will almost always cause problems.
Remember that drag racing engines are usually
stone cold when they go down the race track. We start
the engine and get to the staging lights as quickly as
possible because a cold engine makes more power than a
hot one. Consequently drag racers don’t have the
luxury of an extended warm up period to bring all of the
parts up to operating temperature. In these
circumstances, a little extra clearance is a good thing.
I’m
an advocate of double Spirolox pin retainers. Yes, they
are a pain to install and remove, but that’s exactly
what’s needed in a pin retainer – a lock that
won’t come out on its own.
Wrist
pins aren’t glamorous, but they are absolutely
essential to the health and well being of a racing
engine. Don’t scrimp on pins; a few extra grams of
wrist pin weight can increase your engine’s life
expectancy.
#
# #
|