|
Walking
through the aisles in a supermarket can teach you more
about marketing in the 21st century than a business
school textbook. It's easy to see the hot buttons that
the experts have determined will trigger a purchase
decision for anything from breakfast cereal to dog food:
"New!" "Improved!"
"Natural!" "Low Fat!" "Low
Sodium!" shout the packages. It takes a skeptical
consumer to recognize the hype behind the words. Yes, a
tin of lard is low sodium and natural; that's because
it's pure fat
Like any marketplace, motorsports also has its
share of hyperbole. Racers being racers, they will pay
attention to any product that purports to improve
horsepower, performance or their chances of winning. In
that vein, perhaps the most abused term in racing is
"bolt-on."
This is my last column of the year for National
DRAGSTER, so I will repeat some advice that I've offered
previously. If you are planning to build or extensively
modify an engine during the off-season, please remember
that every part has to work with every other part to
produce a reliable, dependable and powerful engine.
Therefore I urge you to have a healthy skepticism about
"bolt-on" parts.
This is truly the Golden Age of engine building.
Racers have never enjoyed a greater selection of
top-quality, competition-tested parts produced by the
automakers and by aftermarket manufacturers. But while
this huge variety of choices is a blessing for engine
builders, it can also be a curse. There are so many
options now that it is very difficult for even
experienced engine builders to put together a compatible
combination. The choices confronting a novice or
beginning racer are simply overwhelming.
When I started building race engines more than 30
years ago, we had one choice: the small-block Chevy V8.
We used junkyard cylinder heads, junkyard blocks,
junkyard crankshafts. They all came from General Motors,
and for the most part, they were interchangeable. As
long as you remembered the differences in crankshaft
journal diameters between 283, 350 and 400-cubic-inch
blocks, it was fairly simple to bolt together a stout
small-block racing engine. The few "bolt-on"
aftermarket parts we used were limited to rocker arms,
intake manifolds and headers. But even then we often had
to clearance the rocker arms, machine the intake
manifold flanges and rework the header pipes to make
everything fit after we'd machined the blocks and heads.
Now there are literally hundreds of variations on
the basic small-block Chevy theme. There are Gen I, Gen
II and Gen III engines, conventional cooling and
reverse-flow cooling, one-piece crankshaft seals and
two-piece crankshaft seals, internally balanced cranks
and externally balanced cranks, short lifter bosses for
flat tappets and tall lifter bosses for hydraulic roller
lifters - and those are just the factory parts. Add the
options in high-performance and aftermarket parts, with
18-degree, 15-degree and 12-degree heads, aftermarket
cast-iron and aluminum blocks, at least three different
block heights, conventional and raised camshafts - well,
the number of possible combinations is stratospheric.
The same situation exists for virtually every
engine used in racing today. A big-block Chevy V8 can be
built with conventional siamesed-port cylinder heads or
spread-port heads, a factory or aftermarket block, a
production or extra-tall deck height, a standard or
spread oil pan - the list is endless. Ford and Mopar
racers face the same mind-boggling choices.
So when I see a part being promoted as a
"bolt-on," my question is: What does it bolt
onto? To cite one example, you'll find significant
differences in the spark plug locations in big-block
cylinder heads. If you bolt heads with a relatively low
spark plug location onto a block with high-compression
pistons, the domes will almost certainly smash the spark
plug electrodes. Yes, the heads will physically bolt
onto the block -- but the engine won't run with them.
An item as apparently simple as a pushrod
guideplate can cause big problems if doesn't fit a
specific cylinder head. A "universal"
guideplate may not fit any head exactly right; there are
small differences even among conventional big-block head
castings that affect the alignment between the pushrod,
rocker arm and valve stem tip. When you add the
variables of valve stem length, valve angle and valve
centerline locations, it's truly miraculous when
everything lines up.
Some manufacturers recognize the differences
between various components and take steps address them.
Unfortunately, their good intentions can cause new
problems. For example, a distributor with an adjustable
collar would seem to solve the problems created by
differences in block heights, cylinder heads and intake
manifolds. But what's really critical when installing a
distributor in a Chevy small-block or big-block V8 is
the alignment between the groove in the distributor
shaft and the oil gallery in the block. If the groove is
too high or too low, the flow of oil to the lifters and
rocker arms will be cut off. The only way to make sure
that this passage is open is to remove the rear gallery
plug and inspect it visually. If you just drop the
distributor into the block and tighten the adjustable
collar, the distributor gear may not be properly aligned
with the cam gear or the oil pump shaft may not be fully
engaged in the distributor gear.
Building a racing engine is like painting a car -
the preparation takes far longer than the final act. A
competent engine builder can assemble a short block in a
few hours, but it might take weeks to inspect, mock-up,
check clearances and rework all of the parts to work
together properly. Building an engine is not a speed
contest; if you don't have time to do it right the first
time, you'd better have time to do it over again.
Parts that are obviously incompatible are easy to
spot and relatively simple to fix. It's the parts that
are almost right that can be the most troublesome.
Suppose the rocker stud bosses in your new heads aren't
tapped quite deep enough. You torque down your expensive
new shaft-mounted rocker arms and get ready to race.
Unfortunately, the fasteners are bottomed out in their
bolt holes, the rocker stands can move around under
load, and the valvetrain is going to self-destruct on
the first run.
My advice is never to assume that a part is
perfect. Look at every piece and ask, "What could
possibly be wrong?" The guys in our shop build
literally hundreds of engines every year, and it seems
like every day we find some new hiccup that we haven't
seen previously. Last week we had a brand-new engine on
the dyno that had a water leak. The cause turned out to
be a thermostat housing bolt hole that only had three
threads. The bolt was bottoming out and the gasket
wasn't compressed. So now we have one more thing to
check.
Every part in a racing engine is designed and
built by human hands. We know that to err is human, so
it's the responsibility of the engine builder to be the
final inspector. There is a saying among engineers that
Nature always sides with the hidden flaw; our job as
racers is to discover the hidden flaws before they
become obvious problems.
My purpose in writing this column is not to knock the
manufacturers who produce the parts that power our
sport, or the people who package, promote and distribute
them. What I am suggesting is that you regard the claims
for easy, bolt-on installation with the same healthy
skepticism that you would apply to chocolate-coated
breakfast cereal that is billed as low-sodium, low-fat,
low-cholesterol health food. ###
|